The song first appeared in the movie Vogues of 1938, actually released in 1937.
It was immediately a hit in a version recorded by Shep Fields and His Rippling Rhythm Orchestra, considered to have spent fourteen weeks on the charts in 1937, four at #1. (The charts did not actually exist in those days, but reconstructions of what they would have been give those statistics.) A version was also recorded by Jan Garber, which charted at #10.)
Last night I started out happy Last night my heart was so gay Last night I found myself dancing In my fav'rite cabaret you were completely forgotten Just an affair of the past Then suddenly something happened to me And I found my heart beating, oh, so fast
I saw you last night and got that old feeling When you came in sight, I got that old feeling The moment that you danced by, I felt a thrill And when you caught my eye, my heart stood still
Once again I seemed to feel that old yearning Then I knew the spark of love was still burning There'll be no new romance for me, it's foolish to start For that old feeling is still in my heart